Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Noel Gurwick's avatar

A very nice synthesis. Thanks, Bill. There is also a huge process red flag (not that we need any more red flags): All assessments like NCA5 represent the authors' best reading and synthesis of the evidence at a particular point in time. That's why we have a process for updating them periodically (in this case producing NCA6 -- which the US Government would have been doing for the past couple of years had the current leadership in the Executive Branch been following the law -- https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adz3885). Since when in ANY assessment process has anyone picked one particular aspect of the assessment years after publication and proposed going back and "revising" that assessment?

It's perfectly reasonable to publish a paper calling attention to evidence for why a particular part of one of these massive assessments should be viewed differently in light of new developments. Events have always shifted the interpretation of previously-published work. Can you think of a single instance when the response has been to go back and revise the original, very thoroughly-vetted document?

Ready for more?